By Matt Vanacoro
Getting the perfect sounding acoustic guitar ‘sound’ can often be as elusive as my 9-year-old when it’s time to go to the dentist. The ‘holy grail’ tone that you hear on your favorite recordings may seem intimidating to tackle, but it really comes down to knowing your instrument, knowing your recording gear, and knowing how to make those two things work for you, and not against you. You’ve got quite a few choices when picking a mic and a setup for recording an acoustic. Here are my favorite ways to mic the acoustic guitar and get a crystal-clear sound when tracking.
1 – Using A Single Microphone
You’ll want to set the mic up to pick up as much of the natural sound of the instrument that it can. The most common starting point for miking an acoustic guitar is right where the neck meets the body. If the guitar sounds a bit boomy, you can inch it away from the body and a little further up the neck. If the guitar sounds too thin, fix this by moving the mic towards the body. Pointing the mic directly at the sound hole will often give you a heavier mix of lower frequencies and you’ll lose some of the beautiful percussive nature of the instrument.
When you angle your mic, you’ll also want to consider coming in from slightly above or slightly below the guitar. This will give you a bit of safety from the sound hole suddenly pointing directly at the mic when the guitarist invariably shifts a bit. For distance, this can all depend on how much body you want the sound to develop. I’ve seen engineers rig up a mere 2 inches from the instrument and I’ve seen setups that are 3-4 feet away in professional studios. A lot of this can depend on the player and how consistent they are with their dynamics and direction. A player that ‘shifts around’ a lot while they play might not benefit from a mic 2 inches from their instrument as the shifting will cause drastic changes in tone at that proximity.
2 – Sometimes More is More
If you want to leave yourself room for crafting the sound a bit in post, you can always record with more than one microphone, and mix them. Sometimes I’ll be happy with the balance I’m getting at the neck/body junction, but just want a bit more clarity for a particularly exposed phrase or section of a song. In these cases, I’ve often got a second mic a little higher up the neck that I’ll mix in to give me that clarity without sacrificing my ‘golden’ main track. Having a discreet pencil-style condenser like the Samson C02 is great for this purpose as it has a nice and focused cardioid pickup pattern and is small enough not to require a huge footprint as a ‘second’ mic.
Many pencil condensers are packaged in pairs, making them the perfect solution for the ‘spaced pair’ configuration of recording. Combining the C02 mics with a DMA2 dual mic adapter can help you get the right ‘spaced pair’ configuration for recording an acoustic guitar in stereo with a great room.
3 – A Perfect Pair
If you have 2 microphones with a figure 8 pickup pattern (like the bidirectional CL8a) you have a unique opportunity to use a mic technique called a Blumlein pair. This setup is particularly effective if you are going to mic an acoustic guitarist who also sings. The Blumlein placement utilizes 2 microphones with bidirectional pickup patterns. You place them in front of your source ‘head to head’ and configured so that the capsules are crossed at 90 degrees. In this case, what you’ll wind up with is one capsule pointed fairly well to pick up the guitar, and another capsule angled well to pick up the vocals. The mics will be placed at identical distances from the source, resulting in no phasing delay issues that can commonly plague multi-mic setups on instruments and voice. The bidirectional nature of the mics will pick up plenty of the natural reverberations of the room as well, giving you quite a well-polished sound in a good environment!
4 – Flipping the Pair
If you want to record a guitar and give it a real feeling of ‘space’ across the stereo field, you may want to invest some time into learning the Mid/Side technique. It is yet another setup pioneered by Alan Blumlein (see above) but it requires a slightly different configuration and a bit of work on the post-production side. Plugins and built in DAW Mid/Side decoding make this easier than ever to accomplish!
This setup doesn’t require a ‘perfectly matched’ set of mics that you would use for Blumlein pair. You’ll set up the first mic, the ‘Mid’ mic, facing the center of your instrument — just as you would with a single mic. Find that sweet spot for your guitar where the neck meets the body. This mic should be set up in a tight pickup pattern like a cardioid or hypercardioid. You can use a dynamic or a condenser for this mic, you want it to sound good as your ‘primary source’.
Your second mic (the ‘Side’ mic) needs to be a figure-8 pickup pattern. This microphone will *not* be aimed directly at the source, but off-axis by 90 degrees. The Side microphone is going to contain the ambiance and (eventually) the directional sound. When using Mid/Side, I usually simply set one microphone up directly above the other.
The magic is in the mixing with Mid/Side. Your Mid mic should be panned center, that’s the easy part. If you’re not using a plugin which automatically decodes Mid/Side, you’re going to have to get your fingers a bit dirty from here. Essentially, you’re going to want your Side mic to be split to 2 channels, and you’re going to reverse the phase of one of the channels. These channels will be panned 100% hard left and right. This will give you an accurate representation of the stereo ambiance field, and give you control over how much of it you want to hear. The inverted polarity will make the Side mic channels enhance the spacial qualities of your mid channel as you bring it up. You have total control of how ‘wide’ your stereo field is by how much you bring up the Side channels.
5 – It’s Not Just the Mic
You’d be surprised how many folks don’t consider the actual recorded instrument the first part of the chain. Having an instrument that is in top shape should be priority number one. Computer programmers have a saying that I ‘borrow’ when I’m teaching recording techniques, and that is “Garbage In, Garbage Out”. Having the most expensive mic and preamp in the world is only going to give you a crystal clear recording of a crummy guitar if you haven’t properly maintained the instrument. Change your strings regularly!
It might sound crazy to worry about mixing before you’ve even started miking, but having a plan for ‘where you want this instrument to sit’ in the mix can affect the type of tone you pursue. If the acoustic guitar is playing a supporting role in an already thick mix, you might regret aiming for a ‘body heavy’ tone and wind up EQing away a lot of the ‘meat’. Knowing what kind of role the acoustic is going to play in your recording will help you determine whether the instrument needs enough body to ‘stand on its own’ or should be a bit thinner so it can ‘cut through the mix’. Think about what you want this track to do before you start setting up and you’ll save yourself a lot of time later on!
The room and area you’re recording in will often heavily influence what kind of mic you’re going to use. Is the room noisy? Is it isolated from the outside world? What other sounds are you going to pick up when you plug in that fancy condenser mic?
If you have a multi-pattern mic like the Samson CL8a, you’ll want to take the surrounding area into consideration before you choose the pickup pattern. If you’re in a room that has a beautiful natural sound like a treated studio or a hall designed with acoustics in mind, then it’s like you’ll likely be ok with picking up a bit of that natural room sound. Using an omnidirectional setting will allow you have a less ‘focused’ sound and avoid the proximity effect of a highly directional mic.
As you can see, there’s a lot that goes into getting a great acoustic guitar recording. Starting with a great mic is essential, but it is just the tip of the iceberg!
About the Author
Matt Vanacoro is an educator in Westchester, NY. He has been teaching music technology for over 20 years and is a lead trainer at macProVideo.com. Matt is also a contributing author at Ask.Audio with a specialty on tutorials and education. Matt has presented at NYSSMA, WCALA, and NAMM workshops at the state and national level. He focuses on using technology as a formative assessment tool as well as finding technological solutions to help students grow.